feat(decodes): say when the decoder's band is not the rig's

A decoding application that loses its CAT link keeps announcing the last
dial frequency it knew, and every decode after that carries a stale
band. Nothing downstream can tell: the entity verdicts, the band filter
and the FT map all believe it. Seen for real — MSHV kept saying 80 m,
and Korea read as a NEW BAND because on 80 m it would have been.

Said, not decided. Taking the rig's band instead would be wrong for
anyone decoding a second receiver on another band, and a warning costs
that setup nothing but a line to read past. Shown only while CAT is
actually connected: an empty band means there is nothing to compare
with, never that the rig is on no band. Opens 0.27.9.
This commit is contained in:
2026-09-02 10:25:17 +02:00
parent ae8e5b1bc6
commit b7c87def5b
4 changed files with 47 additions and 4 deletions
+10
View File
@@ -1,4 +1,14 @@
[ [
{
"version": "0.27.9",
"date": "",
"en": [
"FT decodes warn when the decoding application announces a band the radio is not on — the signature of a lost CAT link, where it repeats the last frequency it knew and every decode after that carries a stale band. Nothing downstream could tell, so NEW BAND was being judged against a band the operator had left. OpsLog says it rather than deciding: a second receiver on another band is a real setup, and it costs that one only a line to read past."
],
"fr": [
"Les FT decodes signalent quand le logiciel de décodage annonce une bande sur laquelle la radio nest pas — la signature dune liaison CAT perdue, où il répète la dernière fréquence connue et où tous les décodages suivants portent une bande périmée. Rien en aval ne pouvait sen apercevoir : NOUVELLE BANDE était donc jugé sur une bande quittée. OpsLog le dit sans décider à votre place : un second récepteur sur une autre bande est une configuration légitime, et il ne lui en coûte quune ligne à ignorer."
]
},
{ {
"version": "0.27.8", "version": "0.27.8",
"date": "", "date": "",
+3
View File
@@ -6328,6 +6328,9 @@ export default function App() {
txState={txState} txState={txState}
txStates={txStates} txStates={txStates}
spotStatus={spotStatus as any} spotStatus={spotStatus as any}
// Only while CAT is actually connected: an empty band means "nothing to
// compare with", never "the rig is on no band".
rigBand={catState.connected ? (catState.band || '') : ''}
myCall={station.callsign} myCall={station.callsign}
// A click ANSWERS the station: it hands the decode back to WSJT-X/MSHV as // A click ANSWERS the station: it hands the decode back to WSJT-X/MSHV as
// a Reply, which is the same thing as double-clicking the line in their // a Reply, which is the same thing as double-clicking the line in their
+32 -2
View File
@@ -13,7 +13,7 @@
// come from the same resolver the cluster uses, so a call means the same thing in // come from the same resolver the cluster uses, so a call means the same thing in
// both panels rather than being judged twice by two rules. // both panels rather than being judged twice by two rules.
import { useEffect, useMemo, useState } from 'react'; import { useEffect, useMemo, useState } from 'react';
import { Radio, Search, X, Signal, ArrowUpRight, Timer, Trash2, Ban, Columns2, Bot } from 'lucide-react'; import { AlertTriangle, Radio, Search, X, Signal, ArrowUpRight, Timer, Trash2, Ban, Columns2, Bot } from 'lucide-react';
import { cn } from '@/lib/utils'; import { cn } from '@/lib/utils';
import { useI18n } from '@/lib/i18n'; import { useI18n } from '@/lib/i18n';
import { chaseAllows } from '@/lib/spotDisplay'; import { chaseAllows } from '@/lib/spotDisplay';
@@ -95,6 +95,9 @@ interface Props {
// receiver reported last, which is a coin toss — each pane needs its own. // receiver reported last, which is a coin toss — each pane needs its own.
txStates?: Record<string, TxMsg>; txStates?: Record<string, TxMsg>;
spotStatus: Record<string, StatusEntry>; spotStatus: Record<string, StatusEntry>;
// The band the RIG is on, when CAT is connected. Only ever compared with what
// the decoder announces — see the drift warning.
rigBand?: string;
onCall: (d: Decode) => void; onCall: (d: Decode) => void;
myCall?: string; myCall?: string;
// Drop every decode and transmit message held for this panel. The list is a // Drop every decode and transmit message held for this panel. The list is a
@@ -539,7 +542,7 @@ function buildPeriods(filtered: Decode[], txMsgs: TxMsg[]) {
})); }));
} }
export function DecodesPanel({ decodes, txMsgs, txState, txStates, spotStatus, onCall, myCall, onClear, onHalt, autoCallOn, onToggleAutoCall }: Props) { export function DecodesPanel({ decodes, txMsgs, txState, txStates, spotStatus, rigBand, onCall, myCall, onClear, onHalt, autoCallOn, onToggleAutoCall }: Props) {
const { t } = useI18n(); const { t } = useI18n();
// Column widths, dragged in the header and shared by every row. Persisted // Column widths, dragged in the header and shared by every row. Persisted
// through writeUiPref (not raw localStorage) so the layout travels with data/ // through writeUiPref (not raw localStorage) so the layout travels with data/
@@ -597,6 +600,21 @@ export function DecodesPanel({ decodes, txMsgs, txState, txStates, spotStatus, o
// The mode currently on the air, for the slot clock. The newest decode knows // The mode currently on the air, for the slot clock. The newest decode knows
// best; between overs the transmit state still does. // best; between overs the transmit state still does.
// A decoder that has lost its CAT link keeps announcing the last dial
// frequency it knew, and every decode after that carries a stale band. Nothing
// downstream can tell: the entity verdicts, the band filter and the FT map all
// believe what the decoder said, and an operator ends up reading NEW BAND for a
// band they are not on. (Seen for real: MSHV lost CAT, kept saying 80 m, and
// Korea showed as a new band because on 80 m it would have been.)
//
// Said, not decided. Using the rig's band instead would be wrong for anyone
// decoding a second receiver on another band, and a warning costs that setup
// nothing but a line it can read past.
const decoderBand = decodes.length ? (decodes[decodes.length - 1].band ?? '') : '';
const bandDrift = !!rigBand && !!decoderBand
&& rigBand.toLowerCase() !== decoderBand.toLowerCase();
const driftInstance = decodes.length ? (decodes[decodes.length - 1].instance ?? '') : '';
const liveMode = decodes.length ? decodes[decodes.length - 1].mode : txState?.mode; const liveMode = decodes.length ? decodes[decodes.length - 1].mode : txState?.mode;
const liveTr = trSeconds(liveMode, decodes.length ? decodes[decodes.length - 1].tr_period : undefined); const liveTr = trSeconds(liveMode, decodes.length ? decodes[decodes.length - 1].tr_period : undefined);
@@ -733,6 +751,18 @@ export function DecodesPanel({ decodes, txMsgs, txState, txStates, spotStatus, o
what the transmit state reports, so it is right the moment anything what the transmit state reports, so it is right the moment anything
is heard and keeps running when the band goes quiet. */} is heard and keeps running when the band goes quiet. */}
<PeriodClock trSec={liveTr} mode={liveMode} /> <PeriodClock trSec={liveTr} mode={liveMode} />
{bandDrift && (
<span
title={t('dec.bandDriftTip')}
className="inline-flex items-center gap-1 rounded-full border border-warning px-2 py-0.5 text-[11px] font-semibold text-warning">
<AlertTriangle className="size-3.5" />
{t('dec.bandDrift', {
app: driftInstance || t('dec.bandDriftApp'),
dec: decoderBand.toUpperCase(),
rig: (rigBand ?? '').toUpperCase(),
})}
</span>
)}
<span className="w-px h-5 bg-border/60 mx-1" /> <span className="w-px h-5 bg-border/60 mx-1" />
<button type="button" className={chip(cqOnly, 'success')} onClick={() => setCqOnly(!cqOnly)}> <button type="button" className={chip(cqOnly, 'success')} onClick={() => setCqOnly(!cqOnly)}>
+2 -2
View File
@@ -162,7 +162,7 @@ const en: Dict = {
'mx.tipThisCall': 'already worked with this callsign', 'mx.tipThisCall': 'already worked with this callsign',
'mx.tipThisCallConf': 'already confirmed with this callsign', 'mx.tipThisCallConf': 'already confirmed with this callsign',
// FTx decodes panel (Tools -> FT decodes) // FTx decodes panel (Tools -> FT decodes)
'ftmap.tab': 'FT Map', 'ftmap.noGrid': 'Set your station grid in Preferences to place the map.', 'dec.tab': 'FT decodes', 'dec.title': 'Decodes', 'dec.cqOnly': 'CQ only', 'ftmap.tab': 'FT Map', 'ftmap.noGrid': 'Set your station grid in Preferences to place the map.', 'dec.tab': 'FT decodes', 'dec.title': 'Decodes', 'dec.bandDrift': '{app} says {dec}, the rig is on {rig}', 'dec.bandDriftApp': 'the decoder', 'dec.bandDriftTip': 'The decoding application is announcing a band the radio is not on — it has most likely lost its CAT link and is repeating the last frequency it knew. Every decode below carries that band, so the NEW / NEW BAND verdicts are judged against it.', 'dec.cqOnly': 'CQ only',
'dec.allBands': 'All bands', 'dec.allModes': 'All modes', 'toast.qsoLogged': 'QSO logged', 'dec.contsHint': 'Continents: click to keep one or several', 'dec.allConts': 'All continents', 'dec.allBands': 'All bands', 'dec.allModes': 'All modes', 'toast.qsoLogged': 'QSO logged', 'dec.contsHint': 'Continents: click to keep one or several', 'dec.allConts': 'All continents',
'dec.minSnrTitle': 'Hide anything weaker than this SNR', 'dec.searchPh': 'Call, grid or message', 'dec.minSnrTitle': 'Hide anything weaker than this SNR', 'dec.searchPh': 'Call, grid or message',
'dec.clearFilters': 'Clear', 'dec.live': 'live', 'dec.tx': 'TX', 'dec.clearFilters': 'Clear', 'dec.live': 'live', 'dec.tx': 'TX',
@@ -682,7 +682,7 @@ const fr: Dict = {
'mx.tipThisCall': 'déjà contacté avec cet indicatif', 'mx.tipThisCall': 'déjà contacté avec cet indicatif',
'mx.tipThisCallConf': 'déjà confirmé avec cet indicatif', 'mx.tipThisCallConf': 'déjà confirmé avec cet indicatif',
// Panneau des decodes FTx (Outils -> Decodes FT) // Panneau des decodes FTx (Outils -> Decodes FT)
'ftmap.tab': 'FT Map', 'ftmap.noGrid': 'Renseigne ton locator dans les Préférences pour placer la carte.', 'dec.tab': 'Decodes FT', 'dec.title': 'Decodes', 'dec.cqOnly': 'CQ seulement', 'ftmap.tab': 'FT Map', 'ftmap.noGrid': 'Renseigne ton locator dans les Préférences pour placer la carte.', 'dec.tab': 'Decodes FT', 'dec.title': 'Decodes', 'dec.bandDrift': '{app} annonce {dec}, le poste est sur {rig}', 'dec.bandDriftApp': 'le décodeur', 'dec.bandDriftTip': 'Le logiciel de décodage annonce une bande sur laquelle la radio nest pas — il a très probablement perdu sa liaison CAT et répète la dernière fréquence connue. Tous les décodages ci-dessous portent cette bande, et les verdicts NOUVEAU / NOUVELLE BANDE sont jugés dessus.', 'dec.cqOnly': 'CQ seulement',
'dec.allBands': 'Toutes bandes', 'dec.allModes': 'Tous modes', 'toast.qsoLogged': 'QSO enregistré', 'dec.contsHint': 'Continents : clique pour en garder un ou plusieurs', 'dec.allConts': 'Tous continents', 'dec.allBands': 'Toutes bandes', 'dec.allModes': 'Tous modes', 'toast.qsoLogged': 'QSO enregistré', 'dec.contsHint': 'Continents : clique pour en garder un ou plusieurs', 'dec.allConts': 'Tous continents',
'dec.minSnrTitle': 'Masquer tout ce qui est plus faible que ce rapport', 'dec.searchPh': 'Indicatif, locator ou message', 'dec.minSnrTitle': 'Masquer tout ce qui est plus faible que ce rapport', 'dec.searchPh': 'Indicatif, locator ou message',
'dec.clearFilters': 'Effacer', 'dec.live': 'en direct', 'dec.tx': 'TX', 'dec.clearFilters': 'Effacer', 'dec.live': 'en direct', 'dec.tx': 'TX',