Reported: ten fresh contacts upload and appear on LoTW; twenty older ones,
bulk-edited to exactly the same LOTW_SENT/RCVD state, are accepted by OpsLog
and never arrive. The operator's reading was that a failed attempt could not be
overridden. It is simpler and worse than that.
TQSL's exit codes, from its own cmdline documentation:
8 NO QSOs were processed — already uploaded OR OUT OF DATE RANGE
9 some processed, some ignored — same two reasons
14 some already uploaded, the rest signed
8 and 9 were both read as plain success. So on 8 — nothing uploaded at all —
OpsLog announced "already uploaded (duplicate)" and stamped every selected
contact as sent. They were never on LoTW and now looked as if they were, which
is exactly the reported symptom, and it is not recoverable by re-uploading
because the operator has no reason to try.
"Out of date range" is the cause that bites here: a contact older than the
callsign certificate's validity is silently left out. Older QSOs failing while
today's succeed is the signature.
Now: 8 is a failure and nothing is stamped — a duplicate left at "R" is
harmless and will be refused again, whereas a contact wrongly marked sent is
one nobody will look at twice. 9 and 14 succeed but carry Ignored, and the
caller says so in the console and a toast.
TQSL's own sentence ("20 QSO records are out of date range") is captured and
shown. It was being read and thrown away, and it is the whole answer to "why is
my contact not on LoTW".
Opt-in, off by default: neither service can undo it, and a local delete is not
always a statement about the world — a duplicate cleared out of a contest log
was never meant to change the DX's log.
The two APIs are not alike, and the difference decides what is possible:
- Club Log deletes by MATCH (callsign, exact timestamp, band number), so it
works for every QSO in the log, past or future. The band table is its own
list and is pinned by a test: a band mapped to the wrong number does not
fail, it points the delete at a different QSO.
- QRZ.com deletes ONLY by logid. So markExtUploaded now stores the LOGID it
already received on every upload — it was being logged and thrown away. A
QSO uploaded before this cannot be withdrawn from here at all, and the log
says so by name rather than leaving the operator to assume it worked.
Both run BEFORE the local delete, because both need the QSO's own fields to
find their copy and there is nothing left to ask with once the row is gone.
Neither can block it: the operator asked for the QSO to go, and a refusing
website is not a reason to keep it.
rouggy
